Review of a Review

Abstract

To the Editor of the Michigan Law Review: In an interesting review of Walsh on Equity, in 29 Mich. L. Rev. 1122 (June 1931), Professor Clarence D. Walsh appears to ascribe to me parenthood for some pleading concepts set forth in that excellent treatise (of which I heartily approve; compare my review in 8 New York University Law Quarterly Review 521, March, 1931). Although these ideas have been supported by able writers and courts for some time, I should not object to the honor but for the fact that Professor Laylin also seems to assume premises which in my opinion are most inimical to code reform.